| Latest Forum Topics / Sunningdale Tech |
|
|
Sunningdale Tech
|
|||||
|
iinvestor
Veteran |
15-Jan-2021 17:54
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
This offer is doomed to fail....waste of money to go through the nonsense. Just focus on the biz...dont chut pattern with sly financial tactics. Want to sell...all band together and sell to highest bidder...not some lousy PE other PE takeovers at decent price ok!! | ||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
FaceTheFact
Member |
15-Jan-2021 15:36
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Extracted from Quartz write-up.... Mr Koh Boon Hwee is widely respected as one of the top industrialists in Singapore with a prominent track record of achievements.  We call on Mr Koh Boon Hwee as the Chairman of Sunningdale Tech and SIC to protect the interest of minority shareholders  and negotiate for a fairer deal. 
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|
|||||
|
nea03177
Senior |
15-Jan-2021 14:02
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Done. Clicked on link and provided my email address
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
FaceTheFact
Member |
15-Jan-2021 13:40
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Note that Quartz only has 6% and needs every minority shareholder' s support. We need to make the numbers and hopefully escalate the case, as a big group, to make it known to the BOD & the relevant Authorities. Pse act soon. Thanks. | ||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
angsua3761
Member |
15-Jan-2021 12:48
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Many Thanks to Quartz for starting this channel to link the minority shareholders in providing the facts and figures of the offer. Yes i have subscribed to the website to support the motion  
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|
|||||
|
FaceTheFact
Member |
15-Jan-2021 12:32
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Hi All, pse go and support this cause. We CAN' T let our hard-earned money to flow to these greedy businessmen with poor morals! You have to guard your own interest. Only need your email address to register your displeasures. Thanks. We invite all Sunningdale tech SHAREHOLDERS to visit AND REGISTER AT the website we have prepared for informational purposes at  www.protectsunningdale.com.
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
Jamesbond007
Veteran |
15-Jan-2021 09:27
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
I was wrong in my judgement.
Business can sometimes lead one astray..
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
WBdisciple
Elite |
15-Jan-2021 08:52
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Novos fund' s recent acqusitions of companies have boosted share price of these companies EXCEPT for SUNNINGDALE.. Puzzling part is that the directors involved agree to this low low price... |
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|
|||||
|
PQTPQK
Supreme |
14-Jan-2021 22:27
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
When will be the last date to accept the offer?
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
Fataaa
Senior |
14-Jan-2021 21:53
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
I hope some vigilante will come and offer the 2 fookers 1.56 and ask them F O! KBH have lost all the respect for many who had follow him.... | ||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
Sgsginvestor5
Member |
14-Jan-2021 21:38
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
The Quarz guys are opposing the bad takeover!   WWW.PROTECTSUNNINGDALE.COM  OPPORTUNISTIC TAKEOVER OFFER BY SUNRISE AT S$1.55 PER SHARESEVERELY UNDERVALUES SUNNINGDALE TECH   SHAREHOLDERS SHOULD UNITE AND NEGOTIATE FOR BETTER PRICE OR VOTE DOWN PROPOSED TAKEOVER Dear Mr. Koh, Mr Khoo and Members of the Board, Quarz Capital advises entities that collectively own more than 6% of the shares of Sunningdale Tech Ltd (the &ldquo Company&rdquo , &ldquo Firm&rdquo , &ldquo Sunningdale Tech&rdquo , &rdquo Sunningdale&rdquo , &ldquo SUNN&rdquo or &ldquo SUNN&rdquo ). We have been a long-term shareholder of Sunningdale Tech which is one of the leading precision plastic engineering players globally with manufacturing facilities in Singapore, China, Malaysia, Indonesia, Mexico and Brazil. Sunrise Technology Investment Holding (&ldquo Sunrise&rdquo ) which is mainly owned by Mr. Koh Boon Hwee and Novo Tellus PE fund 2 (helmed by Mr Loke Wai San), had announced a takeover offer for Sunningdale Tech on 9 November 2020. Since the takeover bid was announced, we have been approached by minority shareholders together holding more than 4% of Sunningdale&rsquo s shares, who have shared their serious concerns about the undervalue offer by Sunrise. We are in complete agreement with them that the &lsquo opportunistic bid&rsquo by Sunrise at S$1.55 per share is too low and significantly undervalues Sunningdale Tech.   Takeover Offer at Unprecedented and Substantial Discount to NAV and Comparable The proposed takeover price at S$1.55 per share is at a significant discount of more than ~22% to Sunningdale&rsquo s Book Value of close to S$2.00[1] per share. Since 2013, the takeovers of comparable companies to Sunningdale have been completed at a premium to book value. This is despite the substantial majority of these comparable companies having been traded at below book value prior to the takeover. This relegates the &lsquo convenient excuse&rsquo to justify the takeover offer for Sunningdale at a substantial discount to book value for the reason that the company has traded below book value in 2019 and 2020), completely irrelevant and absurd. Parties in the Takeover Consortium have Purchased Sunningdale&rsquo s Shares > S$1.55 The lowball offer is even more obvious when compared to Mr. Koh Boon Hwee&rsquo s approximate purchase of 1,000,000 shares in Sunningdale Tech for ~$1.59 per share (~S$1.59million) in March 2017 and 12,998,000 shares for ~S$1.72 (~S$22.3million) in April 2017. Given that Sunningdale has been consistently profitable from 2017-2020 with its net asset value sharply increasing from S$1.78 in Dec 2016 to nearly ~S$2.00 in Sept 2020, it is quite conclusive that the company is currently worth more than in 2017 when Mr Koh Boon Hwee purchased his shares at S$1.72 per share. In fact, Sunningdale share price has traded far above ~S$1.55 per share in 2017.   " Highly Opportunistic" Timing by the Shareholders of Sunrise The takeover timing for Sunningdale Tech by the 2 biggest shareholders of Sunrise appears to be &lsquo highly opportunistic&rsquo . Sunningdale had not long ago completed a heavy and extended investment phase lasting from 2015-2019. While Core Net Profit during this period was ~S$130million, the company only paid out ~S$65million as dividend. Profits retained, cash flow, and proceeds of ~S$29million from the sale of the factory in Zhongshan, all totaling ~S$165million (~S$0.86 per share) of shareholders&rsquo monies were invested to build new factories to increase production capacity, purchase cutting edge technology and equipment and ramp up the technology expertise of Sunningdale Tech. In particular, Sunningdale had embarked on a centralization and shift of its China production from Shanghai to lower cost Chuzhou. This included the construction of its &lsquo megafactory&rsquo of more than 500,000sqft in Chuzhou and fitting out with the state-of-the-art equipment, which was expected to result in substantial benefits from increase in efficiencies due to economics of scale and lower labor cost. Sunningdale also completed its sizeable Penang plant in late 2018 with advanced cleanroom facility to expand its healthcare business alongside its strong automotive and consumer products components segments.  Sunningdale&rsquo s shareholders, including minority shareholders such as ourselves, have endured an extended period of low profitability and return as the company incurred duplication, shifting, and ramp up expenses during which the company substantially built up its production capability and volume in the 2 new plants. The ramp up process was almost completed in late 2019 which would have resulted in a sharp increase in profitability in 2020. However, this was disrupted by the impact of COVID-19 in 2020. Nonetheless, the resilience of Sunningdale&rsquo s profitability and operations, which can be attributed to its substantial investment in high end technology, is evident in 1-3Q2020&rsquo s results. Despite the major lockdown issues globally which heavily disrupted demand and operations, Sunningdale achieved $8.2m of profitability in 1H2020. As the lockdown and business disruptions slightly eased in 3Q2020, Sunningdale&rsquo s profitability jumped to a remarkable S$10.4m of Net Profit in 1 quarter! Excluding one-off items such as governments grant, the core Net Profit of S$8.7m in 3Q2020 was 57% higher Year-on-Year compared to 3Q2019. Sunningdale was also one of the earliest players to build up a high-quality surgical mask lines in Singapore to support the healthcare sector. It was involved in the production of the TraceTogether token and Becton Dickinson rapid COVID-19 test kits. This is in addition to Sunningdale&rsquo s existing broad based tier 1 clientele base with diversified MNCs such as Continental, Magna, Gemalto, Dyson, Roche, Phillips and HP. Given Sunningdale&rsquo s leading capability built up due to the heavy investments made by all shareholders from 2015-2019, we forecast that Sunningdale can achieve a net profit of > S$36.5m in 2021E (P/E 2021E of ~8.1x, EV/EBITDA 2021E of ~3.3x) which makes Sunrise&rsquo s lowball offer at S$1.55 per share absolutely ludicrous.   " Capping Return" to Minorities and &lsquo Privatizing the Substantial Upside&rsquo for Sunrise, in particular Novo Tellus It is thus shocking that instead of allowing long-term minority shareholders who have been with Sunningdale through &lsquo thick and thin&rsquo to benefit from higher profitability from the investments and ramp up of production, the takeover consortium is seemingly &lsquo privatizing the substantial upside&rsquo for itself. In particular, why did Novus Tellus led by Mr Loke Wai San  choose not to buy a 24% stake in Sunningdale directly from the open market? This would have allowed Sunningdale&rsquo s shareholders to choose whether to sell the shares to him or remain invested in the Company. Is it because the price that Novus Tellus would have to pay to purchase the 24% stake from the market will be substantially higher than the lowball takeover price of S$1.55 per share by the consortium? Why should shareholders such as ourselves allow Novus Tellus or Mr Loke to take advantage of us through this inferior takeover offer and &lsquo subsidize&rsquo his Private Equity Fund? Mr Lok Wai San was appointed as an independent director of Sunningdale Tech in July 2018. As an independent director, besides owing fiduciary duties to the Company, he also has a role in safeguarding the interest of minority shareholders of Sunningdale. It is only through his position as an independent director of Sunningdale which enabled him access to firsthand information and to gain deeper insights into the operations and strategy of Sunningdale which were unavailable to any external bidders unless the bidders were to provide a firm commitment. It is thus surprising when Mr Lok teamed up with the takeover consortium to launch a lowball bid for Sunningdale Tech on 9 November 2020. He was then suddenly redesignated as a non-independent director of the Company overnight on 12 November 2020.           " Myth" that Shareholders can Elect to be Part of Sunrise and Benefit from the Upside A number of shareholders who intend to vote for the transaction believe that they will be able to convert all their shares into Sunrise and potentially benefit from the enlarged upside by going private with the consortium. We would like to clarify to these shareholders that while Sunningdale&rsquo s free float is over 65% of Sunningdale&rsquo s total shares, the maximum number of shares in Sunrise allocated to shareholders who elect to join Sunrise is potentially less than 14%[1] of Sunningdale&rsquo s total shareholding. Assuming that the holders of all 65% of the free float would elect to convert their Sunningdale shares into Sunrise&rsquo s shares, only 20% of their Sunningdale shares will be converted due to the pro-rata mechanism. This means that these shareholders who thought that they will be able to fully convert their Sunningdale shares into Sunrise&rsquo s shares and benefit from the upside will be forced to sell 80% of their shareholding at S$1.55 per share to the takeover parties! Even if only holders of 28% of Sunningdale shares elect to convert their shares, only half of their shares will be converted and they will be forced to sell their remaining 50% shares at S$1.55 per share. In essence, minorities holding more than 65% of the total Sunningdale shares are made to squeeze into the &lsquo pin-hole&rsquo of ~14% in the takeover consortium. On the other hand, the consortium parties will quadruple their 15% shareholding in Sunningdale Tech to more than 60% of Sunrise in any situation at the expense of all other shareholders! It is distressing that the takeover offer seems to be designed to potentially take advantage and &lsquo shortchange&rsquo minority investors whether or not they choose to go private with Sunrise, with only the consortium parties emerging as the clear winners. Smaller shareholder who do wish to convert their shares into the illiquid unlisted shares of Sunrise can be &lsquo especially penalized&rsquo . The biggest beneficiary in particular seems to be Novo Tellus Fund who will basically build up a 24% stake in Sunningdale at S$1.55 per share on the backs of &lsquo shortchanged&rsquo investors.   We urge Mr Koh Boon Hwee to Protect Minority Shareholders and Negotiate for a Fairer Deal Mr Koh Boon Hwee is widely respected as one of the top industrialists in Singapore with a prominent track record of achievements. It is incomprehensible why Novus Tellus Fund 2 and Mr Loke Wai San should be allowed to benefit disproportionately through this lowball takeover offer by &lsquo shortchanging&rsquo minority shareholders of Sunningdale Tech who have consistently and unwaveringly supported the company and management for many years. In fact, many of these shareholders are retail investors who have invested in Sunningdale Tech due to the strong reputation of Mr Koh Boon Hwee. We call on Mr Koh Boon Hwee as the Chairman of Sunningdale Tech and the Securities Industry Council (SIC) to protect the interest of minority shareholders such as ourselves and negotiate for a fairer deal.   Quarz Capital is open for constructive negotiation with the bidder for a proposed takeover price in line with THE INTRINSIC VALUE OF SUNNINGDALE TECH LTD.
 
We are actively engaging with other SHAREHOLDERS who also share similar views that the current proposed price significantly undervalues SUNNINGDALE TECH. We will share our views and engage with all Shareholders to ensure that all parties are provided with the necessary information to make an informed decision. We have proven in the past that we will make good on our promise to vote down lowball proposals and that we are capable of uniting minority shareholders against hostile take over offers well below book value. We invite all sunningdale tech SHAREHOLDERS to visit AND REGISTER AT the website we have prepared for informational purposes at www.protectsunningdale.com. [1] Based on the Joint Announcement on 9 November 2020 (pg 3), each Scheme Shareholder can elect S$1.55 of cash per share or 1,550 shares of Sunrise. However, the maximum number of Sunrise shares which can be issued is 49,834,136,123. Given that Yarwood and Mr Goi Seng Hui are also considered as Scheme Shareholders and will be allocated at least 3% each in Sunrise, the maximum number of Sunrise shares which can be allocated to other scheme shareholder (minorities) is only 39,867,309. Dividing this number by 1,550 into equivalent shares of Sunningdale Tech, we obtain a share count of 25,720,844 or 13.3% of Sunningdale&rsquo s total shareholding
 
[1] Based on 1H2020 Financial Results Announcement
  |
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
Sgsginvestor5
Member |
14-Jan-2021 18:14
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Takeover price for Sunningdale Tech at S$1.55 is ' too low' : Quarz Capitalhttps://www.businesstimes.com.sg/companies-markets/takeover-price-for-sunningdale-tech-at-s155-is-too-low-quarz-capital  QUARZ Capital Management said in a statement on Thursday that the proposed takeover price for Sunningdale Tech at S$1.55 per share is " too low" and " significantly undervalues" the precision plastic components manufacturer. The activist investor is therefore appealing for Sunningdale' s chairman Koh Boon Hwee to protect minority shareholders and negotiate for a fairer deal. Last November, Sunningdale Tech had announced that Mr Koh is teaming up with Novo Tellus PE Fund 2 to take the company private at S$1.55 in cash per share via a scheme of arrangement. Mr Koh' s entity, Sunrise Technology Investment Holding II, and a subsidiary of Novo Tellus PE Fund 2 hold a 64 per cent and a 36 per cent stake respectively in the offeror company. Scheme shareholders can choose between receiving S$1.55 in cash per share, or 1,550 shares in Sunrise Technology Investment Holding (Cayman), the holding company of the offeror, at S$0.001 each. However, Quarz, which advises entities that collectively own more than 6 per cent of the shares of Sunningdale Tech, argued that the proposed takeover price at S$1.55 per share is at a significant discount of more than 22 per cent to Sunningdale' s book value of close to S$2 per share.   The fund pointed out that a huge discount is apparent when compared with Mr Koh' s purchase of about one million shares in Sunningdale for about S$1.59 per share in March 2017 and close to 13 million shares for S$1.72 per share in April 2017. It added that the company should now be worth more than that in 2017 given that is has been consistently profitable, and with net asset value increasing from S$1.78 in December 2016 to nearly S$2 September last year. Quarz also argued that long-term minority shareholders who have stuck with Sunningdale should be able to reap the benefits of higher profitability from the " heavy and extended investment phase" between 2015 and 2019. While core net profit during that period of time was S$130 million, the firm only paid out about S$65 million in dividends. Including profits retained, cash flow, and proceeds of about S$29 million from the sale of the factory in Zhongshan totalling S$165 million (S$0.86 per share) of shareholders' monies were invested to build new factories to increase production capacity and ramp up Sunningdale' s technology expertise. These included the centralisation and shift of its China production from Shanghai to lower cost Chuzhou and the completion of its Penang plant in late 2018. Throughout the period of time, Quarz said that Sunningdale' s shareholders, including minority shareholders, " endured an extended period of low profitability and return" . Despite disruptions arising from the pandemic, Sunningdale achieved an S$8.2 million profitability for the first half of 2020. For Q3 2020, net profit jumped to S$10.4 million. Excluding one-off items such as government grants, the core net profit of S$8.7 million for Q3 2020 was 57 per cent higher than the year ago period. Against this backdrop, Quarz is forecasting that Sunningdale can achieve a net profit of of more than S$36.5 million for 2021 with a price-to-earnings ratio of 8.1 times. The statement also questioned the rationale behind Novus Tellus' Loke Wai San' s move to not purchase a 24 per cent stake in Sunningdale directly from the open market. " This would have allowed Sunningdale' s shareholders to choose whether to sell the shares to him or remain invested in the company," said Quarz. In addition, Quarz clarified that while Sunningdale' s free float is over 65 per cent of Sunningdale' s total shares, the maximum number of shares in Sunrise allocated to shareholders who elect to join Sunrise is potentially less than 14 per cent of Sunningdale' s total shareholding. Assuming that the holders of all 65 per cent of the free float would elect to convert their Sunningdale shares into Sunrise' s shares, only 20 per cent of their Sunningdale shares will be converted due to the pro-rata mechanism. This means that these shareholders who thought that they were able to fully convert their Sunningdale shares into Sunrise' s shares and benefit from the upside will be forced to sell 80 per cent of their shareholding at S$1.55 per share to the takeover parties.  
   
  |
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|
|||||
|
bullrun6088
Senior |
13-Jan-2021 09:10
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
his father never teach him properly not to be a crook and take advantage of citizen' s money by this low ball offer???? Offerers going down in history with very bad name and reputations!!!! Cannot be trusted because offerers only know how to take advantage of citizen money!!!! MAS and SGX very bad regulation and supervision cannot make it and allow this low ball to happen!!!!  | ||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
Fataaa
Senior |
12-Jan-2021 22:34
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
F KBH la! He is the fooker who low ball you guys think he will up at all. Perhaps his ploy, up 5 cts all stupidity happy and accept it.  He fooking betray all the shareholders and failed his  fiduciary duty.. | ||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
not_98percent
Senior |
12-Jan-2021 22:04
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
.... otherwise what would you think could be the reason(s) these ppl buying circa $1.54 (or higher)?
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
PQTPQK
Supreme |
12-Jan-2021 21:11
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
when is the last closing date for the take over ??
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
alexmay34
Veteran |
12-Jan-2021 20:48
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
They may also think kbh would raise the price?
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
Sgsginvestor5
Member |
12-Jan-2021 19:05
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Agree. I think they are most probably also unhappy with the lowball offer.
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
not_98percent
Senior |
12-Jan-2021 18:17
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
.... so far no announcement to SGX on them " acting-in-concert" since they are a major s/h (> 5%) and not deemed " supporter" when deal was first announced
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
lausk22
Veteran |
12-Jan-2021 18:04
|
||||
|
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
What happen if Quaerz joins forces with KBH to take the company private?
|
||||
| Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||

